Plug-in Hybrid Cars: Are They All the Same?

Plug-in Hybrid Cars: Are They All the Same?

26.02.2021: Today, Green NCAP announces the environmental performance ratings of 25 new cars including, for the first time, plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs). The results of three – the Kia Niro, Mitsubishi Outlander and Toyota Prius – show that not all plu

Today, Green NCAP announces the environmental performance ratings of 25 new cars including, for the first time, plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (PHEVs).  



The results of three – the Kia Niro, Mitsubishi Outlander and Toyota Prius – show that not all plug- in hybrids offer the same environmental benefits.  


The Hyundai NEXO – a hydrogen fuel-cell vehicle – demonstrates the promise of this developing technology.  The list of tested cars also includes the full electric VW ID.3 and 19 combustion engine cars, of which two – the Škoda Octavia Combi 2.0 TDI and VW Golf 1.5 TSI – stand out from the rest.



When it comes to environmental cleanliness, pure electric vehicles outshine the competition and, with rising consumer  interest, more and more traditional  carmakers  are  getting  serious  about  electric  vehicles. Volkswagen's first standalone electric car, the ID.3, reinforces this message, joining the BEVs previously tested by Green NCAP with a maximum 5-star rating.



The Hyundai NEXO, a hydrogen fuel-cell car, also achieved 5 stars, as it proved to be just as clean as a battery electric vehicle and very nearly as energy efficient.  



Using a fuel-cell to convert hydrogen into electricity, the NEXO emits only water at the tailpipe and offers a driving range unmatched by any available pure electric vehicle, together with re-filling that is as quick and easy as a conventional car. The NEXO result clearly shows the huge potential of the technology, but fuel-cell cars are an obvious choice to most consumers only if sufficient hydrogen fuelling stations were available.



PHEV technology is currently much favoured by manufacturers seeking to reduce their carbon footprint and comply with new emissions legislation.  Marketed as offering "the best of both worlds" – battery-powered cleanliness when it is needed with the driving range of a combustion-engined car – Green NCAP's tests revealed that, even when optimally charged, not all PHEVs are the same.  



Toyota's Prius impresses most with a 4-star rating that beats all but pure electric and hydrogen fuel cell cars.  The Kia Niro follows closely with 3½ stars, but the Mitsubishi Outlander only achieved 2 stars, less than some of the latest Euro 6 compliant petrol or diesel cars.



Euro NCAP Chairman, Niels Jacobsen, said
, "People want independent, transparent information about the environmental impact of cars. These PHEV results show why that is so important. Consumers could be forgiven for thinking that, by buying a car labelled 'PHEV' and keeping it charged all the time, they will be doing their bit for the environment, but these results show that this is not necessarily the case.


The Outlander shows that a big, heavy vehicle with a limited driving range is unlikely to offer any benefit over a conventional car. On the other hand, Toyota, with its long experience of hybrid technology, has done a terrific job and the Prius, properly used, can offer clean, efficient transport.  



It depends on the implementation and hybridisation strategy but what is true of all PHEVs is that they need to be charged regularly and driven as much as possible on battery power if they are to fulfil their potential."



The Toyota Yaris Hybrid further underlines Toyota's expertise in the field of electrification with a respectable 3½ star rating. But it is matched by two conventionally-engined cars, the diesel-powered Škoda Octavia Combi 2.0 TDI and the petrol-fuelled VW Golf 1.5 TSI. These are the best results achieved so far by non-electrified cars.



Niels Jacobsen, "Euro 6 legislation has made a real difference. For the first time, we're seeing cars perform in real world driving the way they promise on the test bench and we should congratulate car manufacturers and emissions engineers for the huge strides they have made in the last few years.



The future looks like it belongs to electric cars of one sort or another but, for now, consumers face a bewildering choice. Green NCAP is here to help them make informed decisions so that we can all contribute now to a cleaner, more sustainable future."



All of the tests in this publication, except those of the Toyota  Prius, were sponsored by the  European Commission as part of the Green Vehicle Index (GVI) project.




Overview of all February 2021 results

 

Audi A3    3 stars   

BMW 1 Series    2 ½ stars   

BMW X1    2 stars   

Citroën C3    3 stars   

Dacia Sandero    2 ½ stars
    
FIAT Panda    2 ½ stars   

Ford Kuga    2 ½ stars   

Honda Civic    2 ½ stars   

Hyundai NEXO    5 stars   

Hyundai Tucson    1 ½ stars   

Kia Niro    3 ½ stars   

Land Rover Discovery Sport    1 1/2 stars

Mazda CX-30    2 ½ stars   

Mercedes-Benz A-Class    2 ½ stars

MINI Cooper    2 ½ stars

Mitsubishi Outlander    2 stars

Opel/Vauxhall Corsa    2 ½ stars

SEAT Leon    3 stars

Škoda Fabia    3 stars

Škoda Octavia    3 ½ stars

Toyota Prius    4 stars

Toyota Yaris    3 ½ stars

Volvo XC60    2 stars

VW Golf    3 ½ stars

VW ID.3      5 stars



For full results, visit www.GreenNCAP.com.

 

 

-NCAP also photo

Permanent-URL: http://www.automobilsport.com/plug-in-hybrid-cars-are-they-all-same---219715.html

26.02.2021 / MaP

More News

Citroën expands its electric range with new ë-Berlingo
24.02.2021
    Citroën has unveiled ë-Berlingo, the brand's new 100% electric MPV capable of up to 174 miles (WLTP).    New Citroën ë-Berlingo is available in two lengths – 'Medium' & 'XL' – and is capable of seating up to seven people, depending on the version.    With hugely more >>
Kia launches ‘KiaCharge’ in the UK – one account, 13,900 charging points
24.02.2021
      KiaCharge provides the most comprehensive access to the UK public charging network    Convenient public charging access for Kia BEV and PHEV drivers    Access to more than 13,900 UK charging more >>
EVA England launches drivers’ survey to improve confidence in the EV public charging experience
23.02.2021
    Electric Vehicle Association England announces a survey of EV drivers in England to ensure the consumer voice is heard    EVA England will use survey responses to feed back to Government consultation on the consumer experience at public chargepoints    The online survey will run for three weeks un more >>
InstaVolt partners with Everrati to power iconic cars into an electric future
22.02.2021
InstaVolt and Everrati have united to provide rapid public charging to some of the world’s most iconic and classic cars.  Leading rapid public charging network InstaVolt, have partnered with Everrati who develop the world’s most iconic more >>
Last-mile delivery and electrification offer opportunities to scooter sharing companies in India
19.02.2021
... says GlobalDataFollowing the news from that India’s two-wheel shared mobility companies Vogo and eBikeGo raised funds to scale up their operations;   Bakar Sadik Agwan, Senior Autom more >>
Bentley sets out path to sustainable, recyclable electric motors
19.02.2021
    Three-year research project aims to deliver breakthrough in rare earth magnet recycling    New recycling process will provide a sustainable source of rare earth magnets for non-traction motor applications    Funded by Office for Zero Emission Vehicles (OZEV) and delivered in partnership with Innovate UK more >>
Volta Trucks selects Proterra to supply the vehicle battery for the full-electric Volta Zero
18.02.2021
Volta Trucks, the full-electric commercial vehicle manufacturer, has selected Proterra, a leading innovator in commercial vehicle electrification technology, as the battery supplier for the Volta Zero. The Volta Zero is the world’s first purpose-built, full-electric 16-tonne commercial vehicle designed specifically for inner city freight distribution. more >>
Opel’s Pioneering Electric Car Ampera - 10th birthday
16.02.2021
    Revolutionary: Ampera established new vehicle segment in Europe in 2011    Convincing concept: Ampera voted “European Car of The Year” in 2012    Powerful: 110 kW (150 hp) electric drive unit develops 370 Nm maximum torque    Stylish and practical: Sleek, futuristic look more >>
The Lotus E-R9: next-generation EV endurance racer showcases innovation in powertrains and aerodynamics
16.02.2021
•    Design study reveals electric race car for 2030•    E-R9 is “partly driven like a car and partly flown like a fighter jet” – Richard Hill, chief aerodynamicist, Lotus•    Active aero package includes ‘morphing’ body panels and aerodynamic control surfaces&bu more >>
CUPRA boosts electrification and starts production of the Formentor e-HYBRID
16.02.2021
    The brand’s second plug-in hybrid model in its three-year history is now on sale and will arrive at dealerships in March    The CUPRA Formentor e-HYBRID, with its 204 and 245PS versions, starts with a production run that will reach 100 units per day in the first few weeks    Griffiths: &ldqu more >>
Polestar 1 order books open for final production run
12.02.2021
    Final build slots for Polestar 1 available; purchase exclusively at polestar.com    Electric performance hybrid with the longest electric-only range of any hybrid is a “technological tour-de-force” more >>
New Opel Combo-e Life: The Everyday Hero Goes Electric
10.02.2021
    Have it all: Electric drive as well as top safety, comfort and convenience       Electric flexibility: Combo-e Life as five or seven seater with long or short wheelbase    Bes more >>
The MINI Electric Collection for the MINI Cooper SE
10.02.2021
New and exclusive features for electric driving pleasureEdition vehicle for the launch of the new edition of the purely electrically powered MINI with modified exterior including Multitone Roof, specific design features, more >>
Top Three Chinese Electric Car Startups Report 18K Deliveries in January 2021...
09.02.2021
.... increasing by up to 470% YoYChinese electric vehicle (EV) makers Nio, Li Auto and Xpeng posted record performance in January.  According to the research data analyzed and published by Comprar Acciones, Nio delivered more >>
Electricity becomes human in this alternative Super Bowl EV ad
05.02.2021
A Los Angeles-based production company, led by Director Jeremy Heslup has created an alternative Super Bowl advert, starring a mysterious ‘Mr. E’ and a 2021 Porsche Taycan Turbo electric vehicle (EV).A staple not only in sport more >>
All systems go for the compact electric car from Mercedes-EQ: The EQA is now available for order
04.02.2021
Environmental bonus of 9000 euros  makes the EQA particularly attractive in GermanyEQA is the name of the entry-level model from the all-electric world of Mercedes-EQ. Prices in Germany start at 47,540.50 euros[i] fo more >>
Nick Heidfeld tests Battista prototype as Hyper GT development accelerates
03.02.2021
• Ex-Formula 1 and Formula E racer Nick Heidfeld brings his expertise to the test programme of the Battista pure-electric hyper GT• Heidfeld joins Vehicle Development team at Nardò Technical Center in Italy for his debut Battista test more >>
AX Electric launched as new research shows more than 55% of drivers thinking about buying an electric car
03.02.2021
    Wide-ranging survey shows two thirds of drivers expect a like-for-like EV while their car is being repaired following an accident    Only a third of drivers would accept a petrol or diesel replacement more >>
Nissan launches LEAF10 special version to celebrate 10 years of the first mass-market electric car
02.02.2021
    Nissan enhances LEAF’s advanced technologies and design with an all-new special version    LEAF10 commemorates a successful decade of electric mobility while drawing inspiration from Nissan Ariya, the 100% electric coupé crossover    Special version gears up for UK launch in February 2021 w more >>
More than a third of van drivers considering switch to electric
29.01.2021
    Survey according to Fiat Professional finds the ‘white van man’ stereotype is on its way out    91 per cent of van drivers in the UK think its vital to be as environmentally friendly as possible    Survey released ahead of Fiat Professional E-Ducato arriving in the UK later in 2021 more >>
Polestar in Chengdu: the guiding star for sustainable manufacturing
27.01.2021
    Polestar Production Centre first car factory in China to attain Gold status in LEED ratings, facilities powered by 100% renewable electricity       Polestar takes holistic approach to sus more >>
XPeng launches OTA upgrade for P7 40+ new functions and 200+ optimized features
27.01.2021
XPeng Inc. (“XPeng” or the “Company”, NYSE: XPEV), a leading Chinese smart electric vehicle (“Smart EV”) company, today released a major over-the-air (OTA) upgrade for its P7 sedan customers in China. The most comprehensive OTA upgrade in the Company’s six-year history, with the largest number of new and optimized functions, this OTA upgrade will delive more >>
SMMT reaction to announcement on building additional battery production in the UK
23.01.2021
Mike Hawes, SMMT Chief Executive, said “The news that the UK will be home to additional battery production in the North East is hugely positive and an essential step in the transformation of the automotive sector to electric motoring. more >>
The EQA - Electric athlete in compact format
21.01.2021
EQA is the name of the new entry-level model to the all-electric world of Mercedes-EQ vehicles. The electro-aesthetics of its design are indicative of the Progressive Luxury of the Mercedes-EQ brand.     more >>
Aiways now also in France: Exclusive partnership with Car East France
20.01.2021
- Market launch also in France with successful digital sales model- Feu Vert committed to service- Aiways U5 (model year 2020) now available at attractive conditionsAiways, the Shanghai-based start-up for electric mobility, is expanding its more >>
Nissan is the UK’s most popular electric car and commercial vehicle brand
19.01.2021
    Nissan is the biggest selling electric vehicle (EV) brand to offer both cars and commercial vehicles, the biggest supplier of e-LCV and second overall in the 2020 UK EV league, with 10,674 registrations    Nissan e-NV200 is the UK&rs more >>
New Nissan Qashqai: Electrified powertrains accelerate Europe’s best-selling crossover into the future
16.01.2021
    Two new powertrains for all-new Qashqai including a 12V mild hybrid and the European debut of Nissan’s e-POWER technology    Refinement, efficiency and EV-driving thrills combine in a segment-first for crossovers thanks to innovative e-POWER system more >>
The Electric Vehicles With The Longest Ranges Revealed
14.01.2021
Fuel efficiency is an increasingly important factor when it comes to buying a new car, whether petrol or electric. How long will a full tank or full charge last? What is the environmental impact?New research from Budget Direct looks at the fuel and charge economy of some of the best-selling cars, to reveal the ones with the longest driving range. more >>
Earth Ride strengthens Hero Electric competitive position in e-2W segment in India, says GlobalData
13.01.2021
Following the news that India-based electric two-wheeler (e-2W) company Hero Electric has partnered with electric vehicle leasing start-up Earth Ride in India;Animesh Kumar, Director of Automotive and Travel & Tourism Consulting at GlobalData, a leadi more >>
Volkswagen brand triples deliveries of all-electric vehicles in 2020
12.01.2021
 Volkswagen Passenger Cars lifts global deliveries of BEV vehicles by 197 percent and of electric vehicles overall by 158 percent  Market leader in electric vehicles in Germany in 2020 as a whole  68,800 units ordered in 20 more >>
Sales launch of the Aiways U5 in Belgium with Cardoen
12.01.2021
- Cardoen Group becomes exclusive sales and service partner in Belgium- Model year 2020 now available at attractive conditionsAiways, the Chinese start-up for electric mobility based in Shanghai, announces its next partner in Europe: In Belgium, Aiways w more >>
CAKE and Dometic announce collaboration to launch electric food delivery box
11.01.2021
this game-changing electric food delivery box technology helps revolutionize last-mile food delivery, keeping food hot or cold while traveling from the food service provider to the consumer   CAKE, the Swedish leader in premium electric off-road motorbik more >>
CAKE launches CAKE connect, a mobile app and connectivity platform
09.01.2021
CAKE’s new mobile app integrates cellular connectivity to the entire line of motorbikes, unlocking an extensive digital services ecosystem for consumers and B2B operators.CAKE, the Swedish leader in premium electric off-road motorbikes, announce more >>
Electric mobility: A Renault Trucks D Wide Z.E. is fitted with solar panels
08.01.2021
Strongly committed to sustainable transport, Rhyner Logistik has just acquired a fully electric Renault Trucks D Wide Z.E. to supply Denner supermarkets. As part of this approach, the Swiss haulier has also fitted solar panels onto the body of the truck to provide power to the refrigeration unit. more >>
New survey reveals EV switchers don’t look back
29.12.2020
Less than 1% of drivers want a return to petrol or dieselA new poll of Zap-Map’s community of electric vehicle (EV) drivers has revealed more than 90% of drivers will not be replacing their current EV with a petrol and diesel vehicle. more >>
Hybrids are not meant for long distances and other false claims
29.12.2020
    From emission-free driving to the peace of mind that comes with driving as far as you want, hybrid cars suit all needs       The SEAT Leon e-HYBRID’s electric range of up to 64 kilometres enables you to m more >>
Volkswagen significantly expands charging infrastructure
29.12.2020
 Over 1,200 charging points already in operation at German sites  Some 750 new charging points to be installed in 2021, including the first High Power Charging stations with up to 300 kW power  Thomas Ulbrich: “We need significantly more charging points in Germany and Europe.”  Charging at home i more >>
e-Golf: Volkswagen prepares to launch the ID.3 at the Transparent Factory in Dresden
24.12.2020
    Production of the e-Golf2 ends today: 50,401 units manufactured in Dresden since March 2017    After rebuilding the production: The first ID.3 roll off the assembly lines at the end of January    Danny Auerswald, head of plant: "With the production of the ID.3 in Dresden, Volkswagen is underlining the importa more >>
Honda e continues to gain accolades
21.12.2020
    Four UK awards for the Honda e against strong competition in several sectors    Broad spread of accolades document and validate the Honda e as top EV car choice    Honda e recognised for its design, technology, ride comfort and manoeuvrability more >>
2001-2021 copyright automobilsport.com