MRI's high false positive rate has little impact on women's choice of preventive mastectomy

26.03.2008: MRI's high false positive rate has little impact on women's choice of preventive mastectomy

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) falsely detects breast cancer in five out of every six positive scans according to new research into the use of MRI for women with a high, inherited risk of developing the disease. However, this high rate of false positives does not have a major impact on a woman’s decision whether or not to have a prophylactic mastectomy.

The study, published today (Wednesday 26 March) in the April issue of the cancer journal, Annals of Oncology [1], also showed that MRI was very good at detecting genuine cases of invasive cancers and ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS), a localised pre-cancer that can develop into invasive breast cancer, although the authors said that improvements in detection were still necessary.

The researchers from the Hereditary Cancer Clinic at Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Centre, Nijmegen, The Netherlands, followed 196 women with a BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation, aged between 21 and 68 for an average of two years (a range of between one and nine years).

Once the women had discovered that they carried a BRCA mutation (which gives a lifetime risk of breast cancer of up to 85 per cent and for ovarian cancer of up to 60 per cent) they made six-monthly visits to hospital to be examined by an experienced medical specialist and to have a mammography and, whenever possible, MRI.

During their first surveillance visit, the researchers recorded whether the women had a preference for ongoing surveillance, or prophylactic mastectomy and/or a prophylactic salpingo-oophorectomy (removal of fallopian tubes and ovaries).

During the period of the study, which ran from 1999 to 2005, 41 per cent (81 of 196) of the women had at least one positive MRI or mammogram; breast cancer was detected in 17 women (11 from scanning, four during prophylactic mastectomy and two during the interval between surveillance visits).

The researchers found that the sensitivity of mammography (the proportion of true positives) was 41 per cent, for MRI it was 60 per cent and for the two combined it was 71 per cent. The specificity of the techniques (proportion of true negatives) was 93 per cent for mammography and 90 per cent for MRI or a combination of the two.

The lead author of the study, Dr Nicoline Hoogerbrugge, associate professor and head of the Hereditary Cancer Clinic, said: "When we looked at the positive MRI results, we found that 83 per cent of them could not be confirmed histologically and were, therefore, false positives: five out of every six positive MRI scans."

The researchers also found that approximately six per cent of the BRCA mutation carriers who had normal findings from their clinical surveillance, mammograms and MRIs, and who underwent an intended prophylactic mastectomy, had an unsuspected malignancy.

One was only four millimetres in size and it is known that MRI and mammograms have difficulty detecting lesions this small, but three were DCIS between six and 15mm. "This indicates that further improvement of early breast cancer detection is still necessary," said Dr Hoogerbrugge.

When interviewed during their first surveillance visit, 58 women (30 per cent) expressed a preference for a prophylactic mastectomy. Three had no preference, and the rest preferred to have ongoing surveillance. After some of these women had a positive scan, mastectomy was carried out in 90 per cent of those women who had expressed a preference for it, and in only 31 per cent of those who had preferred surveillance.

Dr Hoogerbrugge said: "During the first two years after the establishment of a BRCA mutation, four out of every ten female carriers were confronted with an abnormal MRI or mammography result, but this had a limited impact on their choice for prophylactic mastectomy.

The final decision to actually undergo prophylactic mastectomy appeared to be determined more frequently by a woman’s prior preference than by a positive scan. Significantly more women with a prior preference for prophylactic mastectomy opted for it after a positive scan than did women without such prior intention. We found that women with a mother with breast cancer were more likely to have a preference for mastectomy."

She said personal beliefs and the psychological impact of women’s family medical histories seemed to be of major importance in women’s decision-making process. "There are very few data available about how women decide upon prophylactic mastectomy. Both genetic counselling and breast cancer surveillance are events in the entire process of decision-making, but appear to have a limited impact.

"However, the fact that a false positive MRI result has little impact on a woman’s choice of prophylactic mastectomy may indicate that she has made a well-balanced decision on this subject."

The researchers say that while the pros and cons of prophylactic mastectomy for BRCA mutation carriers remain controversial, with the effects on length and quality of life largely unknown, physicians should give detailed and unbiased information on the different treatments available and the breast cancer risk, including the number of malignancies that are not identified during breast cancer surveillance.

Dr Hoogerbrugge said: "It is important to give BRCA mutation carriers correct risk information for the decision process, because preventive surgery is irreversible."

She concluded: "This study has made me realise that for women at high hereditary risk of breast cancer, accurate detection techniques are of the utmost importance, even at the cost of a high false positive rate because most women can cope with a false positive MRI result."


[1] The impact of a false-positive MRI on the choice for mastectomy in BRCA mutation carriers is limited.

Annals of Oncology. doi:10.1093/annonc/mdm537. Ann Oncol 2008; 19: 655-659.


- European Society for Medical Oncology-


26.03.2008 / MaP

More News

Das Deutsche Institut für Menschenrechte  - Informationsportal
... bietet jetzt auf seiner Homepage ein Informationsportal zum Thema Menschenrechte und Entwicklungszusammenarbeit an. Dieses Angebot ist ein Service-Tool und stellt Hintergrundinformationen und weiterführende Quellen zum Thema Menschenrechte zur Verfügung. Direkt zum Online Informationsportal: www. more >>
Zweiter Stopp der Innovationsreporter beim Medizintechnikunternehmen BrainLAB
In einer Zeit, in der Stadtpläne "ein alter Hut" sind, weisen computerge-steuerte Systeme den Weg zum Ziel. Das gilt nicht nur für den Verkehr zwischen Hannover und München. Das PROJEKT-DEUTSCHLANDREISE ist nach der CeBIT ab heute bei BrainLAB zu Gast und blickt mit Hilfe eines bildge-stützten Navigationssystems in den menschlichen Körper. BrainLAB arbeitet an den Operat more >>
China Bionanometer Industries Corporation Announces New Products for China
China Bionanometer Industries Corporation (Pink Sheets: CBIU - News), a leading company within the bionanometer industry, will soon introduce new products in 2008 after nearly one year of scientific verification, research and experiments, on the prevention and treatment of influenza -- the "Anti-influenza O more >>
China BioNanometer (CBIU) Announces Breakthrough Nanotech Oral Flu Prevention Granules
One of the World’s Few Profitable NanoBiotechnology Company The market in China for nanotechnology products and systems was US$ 5.4 billion in 2005 and will increase to US$ 31.4 Billion by 2010 and US$ 144 Billion by 2015 Many people don't know it yet, but we're in the begin more >>
UAE Women are not aware of vital health issues
Survey reveals women in the UAE need more education to address life-threatening health risks Latest research by IIR Middle East, organizers of Women’s Healthcare, indicates women are not as educated and aware of vital healthcare issues s more >>
OJSC ArcelorMittal Kryviy Rih Health and Safety compliant
Open Joint Stock Company "ArcelorMittal Kryviy Rih" in Ukraine has received the certificate of Health and Safety management system compliance to international standard OHSAS 18001:1999. OHSAS is one of the leading documents for industrial Health and Safety management systems of different c more >>
Rewe will Medikamente verkaufen
Nach den Drogeriemarktketten Schlecker, dm und Rossmann rüstet sich nun auch der Kölner Lebensmittelhändler Rewe, um in den Medikamentenverkauf einzusteigen. "Wir stehen mitten in den Startlöchern", zitiert das "Handelsblatt" in seiner Donnerstagsausgabe Konzernvorstand Josef Sanktjohanser. Derzeit prüfe Rewe mehrere Optionen für das Apothekengeschäft. more >>
ArcelorMittal Tubarão donates equipment to local state hospital (Brazil)
ArcelorMittal makes Health and Safety a priority and ArcelorMittal Tubarão has done just that. By donating an Arteriograph to the government-run São Lucas hospital, ArcelorMittal will help the institution provide better treatment, faster diagnosis and shorter periods of hospitalisation for the benefit of patients across the state of Espiríto Santo, southeast Brazil. The A more >>
Volkswagen Individual spendet für krebskranke Kinder
Volkswagen Individual unterstützt das ehrenamtliche Engagement des Fördervereins „Heidi" für krebskranke Kinder e.V. in Wolfsburg mit einem Volkswagen Polo. Das in Zusammenarbeit mit dem Berliner Kinderkunstmuseum mit Pinguinen bemalte Fahrzeug wurde heute in Wolfsburg an die Vorsitzende des Vereins, Jutta Hammermeister, übergeben. Im Rahmen einer Kooperation mit dem Kin more >>
Rund 3.200 Mitarbeiter besuchten die Gesundheitsmesse bei Volkswagen Salzgitter
Gesundheitswoche erfolgreich beendet Mit einer hohen Beteiligung endete am gestrigen Dienstag die erste Gesundheitswoche bei Volkswagen Salzgitter. Etwa 3.200 Mitarbeiterinnen und Mitarbeiter des Volkswagen Motorenwerks nutzten die Gele more >>
Gesundheitswoche bei Volkswagen Salzgitter
Alles rund ums Thema Gesundheit an einem Ort Im Rahmen der Gesundheitswoche 2008 bei Volkswagen Salzgitter können sich die Werksangehörigen am 24. und 25. sowie am 28. und 29. Januar in der Halle 1, jeweils in der Zeit von 08.00 bis 17.00 Uhr, mit den für Fragen rund um die Gesundheit Verantwortlichen unterhalten, sich über individuelle Kurse und Angebote informier more >>
Ärztekammer erklärt 2008 zum "Jahr der Gesundheitsvorsorge
Präventionskampagne soll auch gesellschaftliche Tabus brechen - Im Rahmen einer Pressekonferenz hat heute, Mittwoch, die Wiener Ärztekammer 2008 zum "Jahr der Gesundheitsvorsorge" erklärt. "Das ganze Jahr hindurch werden Vorsorge und gesunder Lebensstil einen Schwerpunkt im Engagement der Ärztekammer darstellen", betonte dazu Ärztekammerpräsident Walter Dorner. more >>
AUDI AG received the ‘JobErfolg 2007
- Menschen mit Behinderung am Arbeitsplatz’ (‘Job Success 2007- Disabled People at the Workplace’) integration prize at the beginning of December. Dr. Werner Widuckel, Member of the Board of the Management at Audi for Human Resources, accepted the prize from a representative of the Bavarian government in the category "private commercial sector’. It rewards more >>
Schlemmen ohne Reue
- Ernährungstipps für Diabetiker zur Weihnachtszeit   Weihnachten steht vor der Tür - und damit die Zeit von Lebkuchen, Stollen und Gänsebraten. Beachten Diabetiker einige einfache Tipps, können auch sie sorglos saisonale Leckereien genießen. Seit der Aufhebung des "Zuckerverbots" für Diabetiker hat sich bei der Nahrungsmittelauswahl viel geändert more >>
BIOTECHNICA AMERICA - New platform for the life science industries in North America
- BIOTECHNICA AMERICA enters into trade show alliance with America's   INTERPHEX and PharmaMedDevice - Three parallel events and a supporting congress in Philadelphia - Concentration of pharmaceutical and biotech companies under one roof   A new life science event in America is about to make headlines. Next year will more >>
Vom richtigen Umgang mit Ölen und Fetten in der Küche
Natürliche Inhaltsstoffe erhalten – Entstehung von Schadstoffen vermeiden Profi-Tipps von Florian Klinger, Küchenchef im VIVA am Wörthersee Hochwertige Speise-Öle und -Fette gehören in jede Küche. Sie sind wichtige Geschmacksträger und richtig genutzt wahre Gesundheitsspender. Doch bei unsachgemäßer Verwendung kehrt sich der positive Effekt schnell i more >>
EU-Kommission bestätigt: Österreicher sind zufriedene Versicherungskunden!
Die österreichischen VersicherungskundInnen gehören zu den zufriedensten in ganz Europa! Zu diesem Schluss kommt eine Studie der EU-Kommission, die in 25 Ländern durchgeführt und 2007 veröffentlicht wurde. In den Jahren 2003 und 2004 wurde von der GD Gesundheit und Verbraucherschutz in der Europäischen Kommission in 25 EU-Mitgliedsstaaten eine Studie zur Konsumentenzufrie more >>
New products for baby's health
Halal baby foods expansion launched at HALAL World Expo to combat baby anaemia A Mumtaz, one of the UK’s leading Asian foods manufacturers, is launching new Halal baby foods at the Halal World Expo on 9 December 2007. Mumtaz, one of the UK’s leading more >>
Die Entdeckung der Langsamkeit: Kulinarische Auszeit am Wörthersee
Neu Essen lernen im VIVA, Zentrum für MODERNE MAYR MEDIZIN Gourmets und Genuss-Menschen, Kantinen-Esser, Kneipengänger und Fast Food- Anhänger – sie alle beschleichen regelmäßig Zweifel an ihrem Lebensstil. Kann das auf Dauer gut gehen? Genuss ohne Ende oder vielleicht schon bald Schluss mit lustig? Du bist, was Du isst – das alte Sprichwort gewinnt vor d more >>
Medical tourism more popular with Arabs than ever say experts at Clinique La Prairie Clinique La Prairie’s new packages combine its medical expertise with relaxation and luxurious surroundings. Middle East travellers are being offered a healthy holiday alternative more >>
VOGELGRIPPE LUXEMBURG - Remich verbietet Füttern von Wasservögeln und Vorsichtsmassnahmen
Moselgemeinde ergreift selbstständig Vorsichtsmaßnahmen gegen Vogelgrippe In Remich ist seit Dienstag das Füttern von Wasservögeln aller Art untersagt. Bürgermeister Jeannot Belling hat entlang der Mosel zwölf Warntafeln anbringen lassen. Bereits in der Gemeinderatssitzung am Mittwochabend letzter Woche hatte Remichs Bürgermeister Belling kritisiert, dass more >>
Nattokinase - Participating in the Health Food Market
With commercial launch of the nutritional supplement ingredient known as "Nattokinase," Honda Trading is making further inroads into the health food market. "Natto," a traditional Japanese food made from fermented soybeans, has long been noted for various benefits to human health. HT focused on this as a research topic and was working on ways to commercialize it with Dr. Hiroyuki more >>
HEALTH - ASKLEPIOS Neurologische Klinik Falkenstein - Wohlfühl-Reha mitten im Heilklima-Park Hochtaunus
more >>
HEALTH : Prof. Dr. med. Rudolf FAHLBUSCH KOMPETZEN: Hypophysentumore- Neuronavigation INI Hannover
Hypophysentumore Patienten mit Verdacht auf intrakranielle Prozesse wie Hirntumore (Gliome, Meningiome, Schädelbasistumore, u.a.), intrakranielle Gefäßmißbildungen und Hirnblutungen, Schädelverletzungen, Mißbildungen im Gehirn oder Hydrocephalus (Wasserkopf) werden ber more >>
Health: Erste OP mit offenem 1,5 Tesla-Hochfeld-Magnetresonanztomograph zur intraoperativen Bildgebung Leitung Prof. Dr. med. Rudolf Fahlbusch
Unter der Leitung von Prof. Dr. med. Rudolf Fahlbusch wird am International Neuroscience Institute Hannover, der erste OP mit offenem 1,5 Tesla-Hochfeld-Magnetresonanztomograph zur intraoperativen Bildgebung, aufgebaut. Im Gegensatz zur subjektiven Einschätzung des Operateurs über das Ausmaß ein more >>
Prof. Dr. med. Rudolf Fahlbusch ab sofort Direktor des INI - Zentrums für Endokrine Neurochirurgie am International Neuroscience Institute Hannover (INI)
more >>

2001-2023 copyright