Antiquated barriers kill 23 more racers

24.10.2019: By RJ Valentine Research indicates that one driver is dying every single month on tracks with outdated barriers. Since January of 2018, 23 racers lost their lives after impacting with concrete, tire packs, guardrails, fences or berms, and those

By RJ Valentine

Research indicates that one driver is dying every single month on tracks with outdated barriers.   Since January of 2018, 23 racers lost their lives after impacting with concrete, tire packs, guardrails, fences or berms, and those are just the incidents we know of. 

Many different factors cause accidents on race tracks, such as car-to-car contact, mechanical failure, loss of control or driver error.  Beyond wall-related deaths, there have been countless other racing tragedies as well. Nevertheless, no matter what incited the incident, the root cause of 23 racing deaths in the last 21 months involved an unyielding surface.  

Barrier-Related Deaths

Most of the drivers we lost were competing in sanctioned events.  Many were pro racers, others might be semi-pro depending on how much time they spend on track, and some were participating in regional club series or vintage events.  Then there were those whose luck ran out during a test drive, exhibition run, or coaching lesson.  Whether drag racing K-rails are viewed as inevitable or not, there were also four sanctioned events that resulted in death. 

Following is an alphabetical list of drivers who were lost to barrier-related incidents since January 2018.  My sincere apologies if anyone was missed or for any mistakes or misspellings.  

Randy Alexander – May 2018;  Ricardo Barahona – April 2018; Mike Corning – May 2019; Melissa Cothran – August 2018; Charlie Dean – October 2018; Bill Egleston – January 2018; Brody Ford – March 2019; Jeff Green – June 2018; Silas Hiscock Sr. – April 2019; Greg Hodnett – September 2018; Anthoine Hubert – September 2019; Jason Johnson – June 2018; Donnie Large – August 2018; Peter London – April 2019; Daley Mathison – June 2019; Kat Moller – November 2018; Ken Rambo – March 2018; Doug Rose – August 2018; Adam Schatz – July 2018; Thomas Thrash – June 2019; Jim Victor – July 2018; J.J. Wilson – February 2018; Billy Young – July 2018

Though pros only represent a fraction of 1% of all racers, they account for at least 17% of this group.  While less experienced drivers make up the majority of the population, amateur racing isn’t as high profile, thus doesn’t receive as much attention as it should in the grand motorsports safety scheme.  Be that as it may, these fatalities don’t appear to be heavily weighted toward any particular type of racing or level of experience but, they did have one tragic common thread. 

Preventable Inherent Dangers

The fact that racing is intrinsically dangerous is a given.  But it’s unconscionable to continue accepting fatalities and debilitating injuries as par for the course when many could be prevented if the bulk of America’s race track walls weren’t made of concrete, steel or tires.

Has it ever occurred to anyone that no official track rating system or governing organization for track safety exists?  For those drivers who do care about their safety—and there are many—why isn’t there a way to assess potential risks before deciding whether to race on a particular track?

I’ve lost many a night’s sleep, as well as several close racing buddies, over this nightmare that never seems to end.  However, I was gratified to hear about a recent motorsports safety forum of medical leaders who discussed procedures and techniques that could help smaller racing series, tracks or events who lack resources.  At least then they’ll be able to better treat injuries sustained after impacts with hard walls.

I keep hoping sanctioning bodies, series, circuits, or maybe even the drivers themselves, will take charge of this fixable issue.  Though a handful of major sanctions like NASCAR, the FIA, IndyCar, and the Sprint Car Council have taken responsibility for safety mandates, there are still countless other sanctioning bodies and associated series who haven’t.  I’m still counting the years that go by as we wait for track safety to trickle down…and counting the number of drivers lost each month.

Money is not the object

The industry’s overwhelming concern is invariably for the financial well-being of struggling venues.  Okay, then let’s figure out how to subsidize track improvements.  We’ve already invested in equipment and vehicle safety upgrades, so the next logical step is to invest in the facilities themselves. 

Perhaps a “driver safety fund” could be established and administered either by a free-standing entity or through individual sanctions. There are at least 2000 professional racers in the primary series, but the bigger numbers are in amateur racing.  The combined membership of just three of the sanctioning organizations—Porsche Club of America, BMW Car Club of America and Sports Car Club of America—tops a quarter of a million. 

If even 1% contributed $50 each, $125,000 would be pledged for safety improvements.  There are myriad ways funds could be raised to support enhanced safety measures. While creating and managing these programs would take a lot of work, the benefits would be easily measured by the number of lives saved.

Roadblocks and Research

In 2018, I formed Racing Safety United (RSU), of a volunteer-based alliance of 34 representatives from across all areas in motorsports whose mission statement reads “Improve driver protection to reduce injuries, concussions and fatalities at all levels of racing.” 

This new group has been working hard to further racing safety, but has already hit some of the same roadblocks that have historically held back change.  For example, in an effort to acknowledge America’s safest race tracks, RSU developed a new track safety award program.  Ironically, some track owners expressed concern over being recognized for making safety improvements for fear it might raise flags with insurance providers.  So much for the positive approach. 

RSU will soon be releasing the results of an extensive driver safety survey.  Though not completely finalized, the preliminary feedback is quite telling.  When asked whether drivers considered some race tracks more dangerous than others and why, the answers from both pros and amateurs alike pointed to the same circuits, as well as to the exact same hot spots on those courses.  To verify these responses, we researched the history of fatalities and serious accidents at these tracks and at which turns or sections of the track they occurred. Low and behold, the surveyed drivers were right. 

On the other hand, though surveyed fingers pointed at specific tracks and was supported by validating data, the true scope of the track safety issue isn’t fully represented.  There are multitudes of lesser-known venues that are equally, if not more dangerous than tracks mentioned in the survey.  Yet, due to much lower event and participant volumes, they are less likely to be identified. Regardless, almost every driver knows which tracks are riskier than others.

Not to give away too many survey details before it’s released, but most respondents indicated that barrier improvements were a high priority, and many would consider contributing to an official motorsports safety fund to help tracks make these improvements.

Advocating for Safer Racing

I’ve been in love with this sport for over 40 years, but I’ve had enough of its deep-seated denial and penchant for secrecy.  From the beginning, motorsport professionals have been reluctant to speak out about safety concerns.  I’m well aware that this article may ruffle a few feathers and solidify my reputation as an agitator when, in actuality, I’m simply advocating for the protection of life and limb where ever possible. 

How can we stop the killing without killing the excitement?  What can we do to eliminate disabling injuries without crippling the motorsports industry?  Who will take a stand against unnecessary harm?  Continuing to ignore the problem isn’t going to make it go away. 



Regardless of “assumed risk,” it doesn’t make sense to take lives for granted, even your own.  There may be backlash for speaking my mind, but at least I’m attempting to address a preventable hazard that’s been the cause of severe injuries and lost lives for over half a century.  If I’m going about it wrong then, by all means, tell me, and let’s work together to find a better way.

-Kim Miyade


24.10.2019 / MaP

More News

The winners from Audi Sport thrilled workers at two Audi locations in recent days.
In addition to DTM Champion René Rast, Pierre Kaffer and Kelvin van der Linde drove their race cars around the plant premises in Neckarsulm, and Frank Stippler and Dries Vanthoor in Ingolstadt, sharing with the employees the sound and fascination exuded by two Audi R8 LMS: the original winning cars of this year’s 24-hour race at the Nürburgring and the 10 Hours of Suzuka more >>
Audi in Supercar Challenge Assen
From the last grid position to a podium finish: In the finale of the Supercar Challenge at Assen, Bas Koeten Racing in an Audi RS 3 LMS pulled off a sensational comeback in race one. Oscar Gräper/Bas Schouten had entered the race from 22nd, the last spot on the grid, and within just four laps fought back to fourth. By the time the checkered flag fell in the one-hour more >>
Zelos denied famous home victory in physical MINI CHALLENGE finale
•    Talented Norfolk racer scoops Rookie Cup honours in season closer•    21-year-old showcases scintillating speed and racecraft at Snetterton•    ‘2020 starts right now’, vows standout MINI CHALLENGE newcomer more >>
RADICAL SR1 Cup titles decided as Stoney signs off with a double
Champion Shane Stoney may have stolen the show in terms of race wins during the Radical SR1 Cup finale at Snetterton, but the battles for the championship's class titles both went to the wire, with both races producing tight and clean racing.Mar more >>
Sébastien Loeb Racing sur Trophee Andros 2019 - calendrier
Grande Première pour le Sébastien Loeb Racing : l’écurie alsacienne alignera cet hiver deux Andros Sport sur le Trophée Andros. Après le Rallye, le Rallycross, le WTCR…, le SLR se lance un nouveau challenge sur la glace ! more >>
New route announced for 2020 Africa Eco Race
•        2020 Africa Eco Race set to return to mythical Tidjikja in deepest Mauritania   Exciting innovations to a new route for the 2020 Africa E more >>
Volkswagen Motorsport weekend in brief and next up
In briefFrench Rally Cup – Bruno Riberi/Florian Haut-Labourdette (MC/MC), in the Polo GTI R5, won the Rallye Régional Vallée de l'Homme around Eyzies. In doing so, they were also the fastest pair on four of the five special stages.French Rally Cup – At the same time as the successfu more >>
BOSS GP races grande finale in Imola
Europe's fastest racing series excited on the return to Imola with V8 and V10 sound and speeds beyond 300 km/h.-    Double victory for Bracalente-    FORMULA title to Marco more >>
FTP Industrial gains two titles at the FIA European Truck Racing Championship-2019
For the second year in a row, FPT Industrial, together with IVECO, was awarded Team and Drivers’ champion at the FIA European Truck Racing Championship 2019. IVECO was the technical sponsor of the “Die Bullen von IVECO”, the partnership between the Hahn Racing and Schwabentruck Teams, while FPT Industrial is equipping the trucks during the race. more >>
Honda’s Rebelle Rally Teams Navigate 2019 Honda Passport and 2018 Ridgeline Across Nevada and California Desert
    Honda engineers ready for adventure of a lifetime in all-women 2019 Rebelle Rally off-road navigation event    Honda Passport and Ridgeline showcase off-road capabilities of Honda light trucks across 1,600 miles of challenging terrain more >>
Campos Racing’s Master in Motorsport kicks off
The first edition of Campos Racing’s Master in Motorsport, which has a focus on racing engineering and mechanical, has begun this weekThe first edition of Campos Racing’s more >>
BOSS GP Grande Finale in Imola, schedule
The grand finale of the BOSS GP anniversary season will take place from 11 to 13 October – again in Imola after a two-year break.-    Italian duel for the FORMULA title more >>
Robin Rogalski wins Audi Sport Seyffarth R8 LMS Cup
Two victories for Rahel Frey, title for Robin Rogalski: The finale of the Audi Sport Seyffarth R8 LMS Cup delivered suspense up until the end. In the first of two races, Swiss Audi Sport driver Rahel Frey on a wet track fought a gripping battle with her compatriot Rudolf Rhyn, which she won with a one-second advantage. more >>
Saisonfinale der Rundstrecken-Challenge Nürburgring
RCN-Meister gesuchtDer Titelkampf bei der Rundstrecken-Challenge Nürburgring 2019 ist wieder einmal bis zum letzten Veranstaltung offen. Beim Lauf „Rhein- Ruhr“, ausgerichtet von AC Oberhausen e.V. im ADAC, fallen fast alle wichtigen Meiste more >>
Radical Australia Cup New Zealand schedule, entries and stats
2019 Radical Australia CupRnd#6, Highlands Motorsport Park, Cromwell, NZ4-6 October, 2019Schedule: (time - NZDT, GMT+13)Friday, 4 October8:20am - Practice#1 (30-minutes)11:3 more >>
Radical Australia Cup title to be settled in New Zealand
Rnd#6 [FINAL] - 2019 Radical Australia CupHighlands Motorsport Park, Cromwell, NZ4-6 October, 2019The 2019 Radical Australia Cup comes to its conclusion this weekend, with the title contenders heading back to Highlands Motorsp more >>
Class victory in France
In round six of the Trophée Tourisme Endurance, the Audi RS 3 LMS once again proved its endurance racing qualities. On the circuit at Nogaro, the Motorsport Développement team finished overall runners-up and scored victory in the T4 class. After 3h 50m of racing, the driver team of Mané Vignjevic/P more >>
RCN Schwedenkreuz Nürburgring review
Moesgen/Breidenbach siegten bei der achten RCN-VeranstaltungGrandioses 3h-Rennen auf dem NürburgringTolles Spätsommerwetter beim 3h-Rennen „Schwedenkreuz“, der achten Veranstaltung der Rundstrecken-Chal more >>
Superb Stoney secures Radical SR1 Cup crown in style at Donington
Shane Stoney secured the 2019 Radical SR1 Cup Championship title in dominant fashion with a Donington double, putting him clear in the title chase ahead of the season finale at Snetterton.Stoney took his season tally to nine wins from more >>
The fight for the Italian Sports Prototypes marked by Wolf Racing Cars is still open
...after the spectacular weekend in VallelungaExciting and hard-fought, the Italian Sports Prototypes 2019 Championship, the single-make series using the Wolf GB08 Thunder powered by Aprilia 1.0 and fitting Yokohama tyres, confirmed last weekend all more >>
Title showdown beckons for Dan Zelos after stunning second MINI CHALLENGE triumph
•    Norfolk racer charges to hard-fought success at Donington Park•    Sensational pass key to 21-year-old’s second victory of 2019•    MINI UK VIP ace heading to home turf finale in title contention more >>
AMG Driving Academy to start the 2020 season with a new Winter Sporting Programme
-  Sheer adrenalin on snow and ice in Swedish Lapland-    The AMG Driving Academy is revising and extending its driver trai more >>
Gymkhana Grid “Wow” factor in Warsaw: The Solbergs dominate at Gymkhana Grid
An all-Solberg final, thousands of passionate motorsport fans, and a truly spectacular show: Petter Solberg (N) won gold at the Gymkhana Grid in Warsaw – just ahead of his 17-year old son Oliver. This is the third time in a row that the more >>
BOSS GP in Brno - More than just racing
 REVIEW: BOSS GP RACES 9 AND 10 AT MASARYK RACING DAYS IN BRNOThe Big Open Single Seater thrill fans on Czech Republic's fastest roller coaster with exciting races in rainy conditions.-&nb more >>
Jackson edges ahead in Radical Challenge title chase during tight Brands Hatch battle
Of the three Radical Challenge title contenders, championship leader Dominik Jackson will leave Brands Hatch happiest, having edged out his points cushion thanks to two key mistakes for title rival Jérôme de Sadeleer. However, a victory for the Swiss driver limited the damage and keeps the title battle balanced on a knife-edge heading to the series finale at Donington Park later th more >>
Velarde shakes up final Red Bull Air Race World Championship battle with Chiba Qualifying win
As the three pilots still in the fight for the Red Bull Air Race World Championship fought to seize momentum for the season finale in Chiba, Japan, it was an outsider – Spain’s Juan Velarde – who won Qualifying and pole position. more >>
Red Bull Air Race World Championship standings after Chiba, Japan Qualifying
Red Bull Air Race World ChampionshipChiba, JAPANSaturday, September 7th  2019OFFICIAL Result list - Qualifying - MASTERSHeat 11 26 Juan VELARDE ESP Team Velarde 12.596 31.600 48.140 Run more >>
BOSS GP at Masaryk Racing Days in Brno
The economically innovative and aspiring Moravian city of Brno will host the ninth and tenth BOSS Grand Prix 2019.-    BOSS GP title fight is on-    from more >>
The Final Race: Chiba to crown Red Bull Air Race World Champion 2019
For one last time, 14 of the world’s most exceptional pilots will face off at speeds of 370 km/h and forces up to 12 G as the 2019 finale of the Red Bull Air Race World Championship takes off in Chiba, Japan. The crown is still with more >>
Siebter Lauf der Rundstrecken Challenge Nürburgring
Es geht in Richtung MeisterschaftMit der siebten Veranstaltung der Rundstrecken-Challenge Nürburgring biegt die familiäre GT- und Tourenwagen-Breitensportserie auf die Zielgerade der Meisterschaftsentscheidung 2019 ein. Der siebte RCN Lauf, der &bd more >>
Next appearance of the Audi R8 LMS GT2
Following its world premiere at Goodwood on July 5 and its appearance in the formation lap of the 24 Hours of Spa on July 27, the new Audi R8 LMS GT2 was a guest at the next major public event. 53,500 spectators watched the 47th edition of the AvD Oldtimer Grand Prix at the more >>
Team Brit - The next disabled female racing drivers, partners required
NEW PROJECT - SPONSORS REQUIREDWe are super excited about our latest project that aims to recruit at least 3 disabled female rookie racing drivers.This proje more >>
Alex Zanardi: Treble at the Para-cycling World Cup in Canada
BMW works driver and brand ambassador Alessandro Zanardi (ITA) continued his winning run on the international paracycling scene. The Canadian city of Baie-Comeau hosted the UCI Para-cycling Road World Cup at the weekend. Zanardi lined more >>
Formula Student Germany 2019 (FSG) Uni teams successful at the Hockenheimring
Four teams of students from institutes of technology, supported by Volkswagen, made successful appearances at the finale of Formula Student Germany (FSG) at the Hockenheimring from 05 to 11 August. The design competition, in which the teams de more >>
Renault Sport Academy Mid-Season review
For 2019, the Renault Sport Academy – now in its fourth season - took on four new recruits as Chinese drivers Guanyu Zhou and Yifei Ye, Frenchman Anthoine Hubert and Brazilian teenager Caio Collet all joined the programme.Reigning Formula Renault Eurocup ch more >>
Zwei großartige RCN-Rennen im belgischen Spa-Francorchamps
Auslandsstart war ein ErfolgDer sechste Lauf der Rundstrecken-Challenge Nürburgring 2019, das „RCN-Rennen Eau Rouge“, in Spa-Francorchamps (Belgien) war ein großer Erfolg. 109 Teilnehmer zeigten auf der Traditionsrennstrecke in zw more >>
Russian wins first ever Downhill Skate Cross Race
The sport of Ice Cross, which has been a major hit in Europe, Asia and America in recent years thanks to the Red Bull Crashed Ice series, now has a summer version: Downhill Skate Cross. The first race to be organised in this new sport took place this weekend at Patriot Park outsid more >>
Brilliant Zelos breaks through at Brands with maiden MINI victory - seeking for partners
•    Talented Norfolk ace sprints to long-overdue first MINI CHALLENGE success•    MINI UK VIP star is class of the field around challenging former F1 circuit•    21-year-old charges through pack in race two to complete bumper points haul more >>
Santa Pod Raceway’s Drag European Finals meeting fast approaches
... promising a dramatic finish to 2019’s FIA/FIM European Drag Racing Championships. FIA/FIM European FinalsSanta Pod RacewayThu.5 – Sun.8 September 2019Owing to a quirk i more >>


2001-2022 full copyright